Corporate Tax Breaks For Hiring Workers Won’t Work

There is chatter today that Congress is considering new tax breaks for corporations that hire unemployed workers. On the face of it this might seem like a good idea; incentivize companies to start hiring again. The only problem is that this is yet another example of a tax cut that won’t work. Proponents of tax cuts seem to think they can solve any problem in a capitalist economy, but that argument defies logic much of the time.

I have long argued that cutting the capital gains tax from 20% to 15% (as the Republican-led Congress did under President Bush) did nothing to boost demand for stock market related investments. The argument seemed to be that lower tax rates on profits would encourage more capital being allocated to the market, but that conclusion falsely assumed that the chief reason investors buy stocks is to save money on taxes.

In reality, we buy stocks if we think we can make a profit from doing so. Nobody was avoiding the stock market because of a 20% tax rate of capital gains (which, if anything, would encourage investing since it was lower than the income tax rate). They were avoiding the market because they didn’t think they could make good money in it. Cutting the tax rate on stock gains from 20% to 15% doesn’t make investing any more attractive to people because a 20% tax rate wasn’t what was holding them back to begin with.

The situation with any corporate tax break for hiring unemployed workers is essentially the same. Companies don’t hire workers based on tax rates, they hire them based on whether they need them in order to produce the amount of goods and services demanded by their customers. No competent CEO is going to hire a worker he or she doesn’t need simply to get a tax break. That would be like making a charitable donation simply to get the tax deduction (you wind up foolishly spending a dollar in order to save 30 cents).

Don’t get me wrong, I am all in favor of incentives (unfortunately, our country all too often needs to rely on them to get people to do productive things they otherwise wouldn’t), but we have to match up the incentive with the desired behavior. If we don’t, it’s just wasted time, money, and effort.

Enjoy this post? Subscribe and never miss another one: RSS | Email | Twitter

4 Thoughts on “Corporate Tax Breaks For Hiring Workers Won’t Work

  1. Fairly choopy sequence. Yes, the direct benefit to tax cuts for coroporations does not directly lead to hiring. It does , however, leading to better margins, lowe prices, capital expansion, and finally, the need to hire. I cannot get to NYC by stepping out of my door. But, if I add a few steps in between, I am in the Big Apple.

  2. PS cap gains cuts don’t lead to stock buying. They lead to more capital expansion. This, in times leads to higher stocks.

  3. Maybe Bush and all the Republicans should read this post.

  4. mythbuster1 on October 10, 2009 at 8:05 PM said:

    Since small business employs most people in the country, exempt them from all business and payroll taxes. If that happened, Joe the Plumber would buy a business, hire as many people as he could to maximize profits, and reward himself with a new car, new house, new furniture, and take his wife out to a show and nice dinner. Simulus the old fashioned way.

Post Navigation