Economy Continues to Deteriorate, But Stock Market Treads Water

Market strategists call it a “bottoming process” or “building a base.” The chart below shows the S&P 500 over the last three months and you can see what they are talking about. Earnings estimates keep dropping, job cuts keep pushing up the unemployment rate, GDP continues to contract, but the S&P has been going sideways in a range between 750 and 950, even in the face of three months of bad news. No rally has been sustainable, but the market isn’t getting significantly worse.

Some think this trend is a good thing, others would like to see the market rising in the face of bad news, but it is too early for the latter. There is no doubt that it is a positive sign that the market seems to have come to grips with the reality that job losses will continue, corporate profits in 2009 will stink, and the unemployment rate is headed well over 8% this year (from 7.2% currently). Since the market discounts future events ahead of time, current market prices appear to have priced in the consensus economic forecasts for 2009. Of course, we don’t know if those assumptions will prove accurate or not. Only time will tell on that front.

For those looking for a large market advance, we likely won’t get one that is sustainable until the economy shows signs of stabilizing. Just like stocks hit bottom before the economic statistics got worse, stocks will begin to rise before the economy begins to grow again, but we are likely facing months of stagnation before that happens. As a result, the last three months of sideways market action makes sense. Things might not get too much worse than most are expecting, but a recovery is going to take time.

Enjoy this post? Subscribe and never miss another one: RSS | Email | Twitter

2 Thoughts on “Economy Continues to Deteriorate, But Stock Market Treads Water

  1. Pingback: Tuesday Already?? Links

  2. Jim Mullin on February 6, 2009 at 12:18 PM said:

    This economic situation is so fragile that I’m amazed Al Qaeda hasn’t taken advantage. Another 9/11 and we’d be looking at Dow 3000. I guess Putin and Chavez would like to push us off a cliff too but then there’s the small matter of their oil exports. But Al Qaeda, N. Korea, Iran (perhaps) may not be as ‘discerning’.

Post Navigation